Accountability after Inquiry Recommendations: Improving our Patchwork of Scrutiny and Oversight
Lucy Moxham, Henry Screaton, Dr Jan van Zyl Smit
The Bingham Centre has completed a research project which explored how to establish more effective monitoring, oversight and scrutiny of the implementation of public inquiry recommendations in the UK, with the aim of providing greater accountability. We are grateful to the Joseph Rowntree Charitable Trust for its generous support of this project. The findings of that research are now published and available here.
Public inquiry recommendations can be important for addressing the harms an inquiry identifies and for preventing similar harms from occurring in future. They are the result of what is often a costly and lengthy process, which can be traumatic especially for victims and their families. There is, however, an 'implementation gap' between inquiry recommendations and their implementation in practice. When inquiry recommendations go unaddressed, it risks similar harms being repeated, and it risks undermining public trust and confidence in inquiries as an accountability tool.
From a rule of law perspective, inquiries are temporary, ad hoc bodies established in response to complex harms or failures, or events that raise major public concern, which require broader investigation and lesson-learning that go beyond what would normally take place in court proceedings to determine civil or criminal liability. Loss of confidence in the inquiry model would be detrimental to the culture of trust in institutions and bodies on which the rule of law depends.
Part 1: Making inquiry recommendations - Here we consider the number, presentation and categories of recommendations made by public inquiries. We also explore some wider themes relating to the framing and development of inquiry recommendations.
Part 2: Responding to inquiry recommendations and reporting on progress - Here we consider responses to inquiry recommendations, and the way in which progress on the implementation of inquiry recommendations is reported. This includes the new Cabinet Office collection of dashboards, which records public inquiry recommendations made since 2024, the government's response, and implementation updates.
Part 3: Monitoring the implementation of inquiry recommendations - This begins by considering some recent examples of legal cases concerning the response to recommendations, and we see the limitations of legal challenges in this area. Part 3 then considers the role of Parliament, the role of inquiries themselves, the role of other mechanisms (such as the Cabinet Office Inquiries Unit; existing audit institutions; the media; and advocacy groups, the public and those with lived experience of inquiries), proposals for a National Oversight Mechanism and the model of implementation monitors used in Australia.
